Related: Sunday Globe Special: Zimmerman Trial Begins Monday
"Judge in Zimmerman trial blocks testimony on screams" by Kyle Hightower and Mike Schneider | Associated Press, June 23, 2013
SANFORD, Fla. — The judge in the murder trial of George Zimmerman said Saturday that prosecution audio experts who point to Trayvon Martin as screaming on a 911 call moments before he was killed won’t be allowed to testify at trial.
The screams are crucial pieces of evidence because they could determine who the aggressor was in the confrontation before Zimmerman fatally shot the unarmed teenager. Martin’s family contends it was the teen screaming, while Zimmerman’s father has said it was his son.
Judge Debra Nelson ruled that the methods used by the experts aren’t reliable. But her ruling doesn’t prevent the 911 calls from being played at trial.
She reached the decision after hearing arguments that stretched over several days this month on whether to allow testimony from two expert witnesses for the prosecution.
One expert ruled out Zimmerman as the screamer and another said it was Martin. Defense experts argued there was not enough audio to determine who the screams are coming from. Zimmerman’s attorneys also argued that the state experts’ analysis is flawed.
Opening statements are set for Monday in the second-degree murder trial for the former neighborhood watch volunteer who says he fired on the black teenager in self-defense last year. Zimmerman has pleaded not guilty.
The elimination of the audio experts will likely shorten the trial by a week. Before the ruling, attorneys had predicted the trial could last two to four weeks after opening statements.
A spokeswoman for prosecutors didn’t immediately return an e-mail Saturday.
Audio experts from both sides testified at different times during the hearing, which stretched over three weeks. Voice experts were hired by lawyers and news organizations to analyze the calls, which were made during the confrontation between Zimmerman and Martin. The experts arrived at mixed conclusions.
In deciding whether to admit the voice-recognition technology used by prosecution audio experts Tom Owen and Alan Reich, Nelson had to determine whether it is too novel or whether it has been accepted by the scientific community at-large.
‘‘There is no evidence to establish that their scientific techniques have been tested and found reliable,’’ the judge said in her ruling.
Owen was hired by the Orlando Sentinel last year to compare a voice sample of Zimmerman with screams for help captured on 911 calls made by neighbors. He said Zimmerman’s voice doesn’t match the screams. He compared only Zimmerman’s voice to the 911 calls because he didn’t have a voice sample for Martin at the time.
‘‘The screams don’t match at all,’’ Owen testified during the hearing. ‘‘That’s what tells me the screams aren’t George Zimmerman.’’
Owen also testified that remarks Zimmerman made in a conversation with a police dispatcher were obscene but not a racial slur.
Reich testified in a report for prosecutors that the screams on the 911 tapes were from Martin, and the defense does not want him to testify at trial.
Reich’s analysis also picked up words that other experts couldn’t find, including the words, ‘‘This shall be’’ from Zimmerman, and ‘‘I’m begging you’’ from Martin.
Reich’s testimony would ‘‘confuse issues, mislead the jury,’’ the judge said.
In contrast, a British audio expert testified for the defense that it would be extremely difficult to analyze voices by comparing screaming with a normal voice.
‘‘I’ve never come across a case in my 13 years where anybody’s tried to compare screaming to a normal voice,’’ said audio expert Peter French.
A second audio expert for the defense, George Doddington, also criticized prosecution experts who said Friday that screams and pleas on a 911 recording likely belonged to Martin.
‘‘It’s all ridiculous,’’ Doddington said.
A man is dead, and another is on trial for his life! Think what you want of all this, but it's far from ridiculous!
--more--"
Also see:
Week 2 of jury picking resumes in Zimmerman case
All-women jury selected for Zimmerman trial
Prosecutors can say ‘profiled’ at Zimmerman trial
NEXT DAY UPDATE: Zimmerman jury in sequestration
MORE UPDATES:
"The long-awaited murder trial has stirred nationwide debate over racial profiling, vigilantism, and Florida’s expansive laws on the use of deadly force."
