"Plymouth DA faces fire for witness deals; Critics cite ‘win at all costs’ ethic; Cruz defends his ways" by Michael Rezendes Globe Staff July 04, 2015
BROCKTON — District Attorney Timothy J. Cruz built his reputation as a tough-talking law-and-order Republican who doesn’t make deals with criminal defendants.
“We do not plea bargain in this office,” Cruz lectured his staff in 2011. “So if you are not comfortable or do not believe in my policies, then maybe you should not be working here.”
But a review of confidential court documents shows the Plymouth district attorney has repeatedly broken his own rule when it comes to cutting deals with career criminals who promise to help solve the many gang-related homicides that plague Brockton.
Cruz is a hypocrite, huh? Imagine by astonishment.
Although Cruz says his use of cooperating witnesses has been successful, it has come at a steep cost. Grand jury testimony, police interview transcripts, and other documents obtained by the Globe show a pattern of granting favors to violent criminals who continue to commit new crimes almost immediately after being granted leniency.
Hey, it's a good way to keep the money coming in the never-ending battle against crime (that we are told, on the other hand and backed up by actual statistics, that crime is way down and authority doing great job) while justifying the need for your office.
In one case, Cruz took the unusual step of using public funds to bail out a witness who had been captured after a high-speed police chase, only to see the witness rearrested for drug dealing and possession of an illegal firearm three months later. In another, Cruz agreed to reduce an illegal firearms charge against a cooperating witness to keep him out of prison, but the witness was rearrested on numerous other charges and eventually indicted for murder.
I'm about to bail myself.
And, earlier this year, Cruz was forced to drop all charges in two high-profile murder cases after an essential witness whom Cruz had paid to relocate out of state refused to testify. The witness, Nilton Darosa, threatened to kill three officials if they forced him to return to Massachusetts, and was finally arrested for carrying an unlicensed handgun.
Oh, that's nice. What lucky state received him?
Cruz’s handling of cooperating witnesses has helped fuel an exodus from his staff amid charges from several critics that he has a “win at all costs” philosophy, and retaliates against those who question it.
He's acting like they all do; in fact, this qualifies him for federal office.
And Cruz’s top assistant abruptly resigned in April after allegations that he tried to smear the reputation of a former assistant district attorney who had questioned the office’s use of one cooperating witness.
“Cruz has been utterly reckless,” said former Plymouth prosecutor John E. Bradley Jr., who says that Cruz wrongly fired him in 2012 after he refused to make campaign contributions to Cruz, and complained about his use of potentially dangerous cooperating witnesses. “He seemed not to care what crimes the informant committed in the past or what crimes he might commit in the future.”
Bradley, now a prosecutor in Worcester County, has filed a federal civil rights lawsuit against Cruz and two top staff members.
Cruz declined to be interviewed, but in a lengthy written statement to the Globe he said that the deals with cooperating witnesses have helped solve numerous slayings, and noted that, overall, his office won convictions in 84 percent of the 147 homicide prosecutions brought to trial in Plymouth County from 2002 through 2014. He also insisted that he carefully reviews the records of cooperating witnesses before deciding which of them could be trusted to stay out of trouble.
“It’s a difficult decision to make when confronted with a cooperating witness who has credible information and yet brings with him or her a history of their own criminal conduct,” wrote Cruz, who referred to the informants only by number in his statement to protect their privacy. “We have had tremendous successes with cooperating witnesses in Plymouth County.”
Cruz also stands by his record as a manager in 14 years as district attorney.
Time for him to go.
He attributed the numerous departures from his office — 16 senior prosecutors out of a staff of about 50 have left over the last three years — to the “natural course of attrition in a district attorney’s office.”
But some judges, too, have begun questioning the fairness of tactics employed by Cruz’s office.
In the last four months, three judges have separately rebuked Cruz’s office for its handling of cases before them, including the arrest of a crucial defense witness in a murder case moments before he was scheduled to testify. The witness was arrested in a courthouse hallway, with the approval of Cruz’s prosecutor, and hauled away in a police cruiser for an unpaid motor vehicle violation.
“There was absolutely no intention . . . to prevent a witness from testifying for the defense,” Cruz said in his statement to the Globe.
However, Judge Richard J. Chin concluded otherwise, finding that the courthouse arrest was “misconduct on the part of the government” and “intimidation of a witness.”
Your spot in the FBI is waiting.
In a second case, Judge Cornelius J. Moriarty II scolded Cruz’s office for trying to portray a defense witness as dishonest and unreliable when it had previously allowed her to testify as a witness for the prosecution in another case.
(Blog editor snorts)
The witness, former Plymouth prosecutor Karen H. O’Sullivan, had testified last year for the state in a perjury case. But when O’Sullivan was about to testify for the defense in a murder case this winter, Cruz’s top assistant, Frank J. Middleton Jr., attempted to discredit her by introducing caustic memos about her written by Middleton and other colleagues in the Plymouth DA’s office, along with racially charged e-mails that O’Sullivan had sent or received.
Maybe you want to read through them?
If O’Sullivan, now a first assistant DA in Bristol County, were so unreliable, Judge Moriarty asked, why had Cruz’s office ever relied on her as a witness?
“Frankly, sir, this bothers me,” Moriarty said to one of Cruz’s prosecutors during a March hearing.
A third judge, Mark S. Coven, faulted Cruz for something he failed to do: seek criminal charges against guards at Bridgewater State Hospital in the case of patient who died while being subdued. Cruz said charges were unwarranted despite a medical examiner’s finding that the guards’ rough treatment caused the death of Joshua K. Messier in 2009.
Yeah, that turned into a real mess.
Coven, who reviewed the case this year, wrote that “any objectively reasonable person” would have seen that the actions of the guards “involved a high degree of likelihood that substantial harm would result.” The guards now face involuntary manslaughter charges, after a special prosecutor took Coven’s findings before a grand jury this spring.
A witness with baggage
The bitter internal dispute over Cruz’s use of witnesses with criminal backgrounds began in November 2010 when a drug dealer eager to get out of jail called investigators with an offer.
Kashin Nembhard, who had just been arrested after a high-speed chase in a car littered with 30 bags of heroin and cocaine, told prosecutors he had witnessed the killing of 23-year-old Antonio Centeio during a wild shootout at a Hess gas station in Brockton in 2009. He could identify the shooter and help solve other crimes, too, he said — if they would help him with his $5,000 bail.
State Police troopers working for Cruz’s office negotiated Nembhard’s bail down to $350, then paid it with public funds and taped a statement by their new star witness, records show. Then they took Nembhard out for lunch.
Your TAX DOLLARS at WORK!
R. Michael Cassidy, a Boston College Law School professor and former head of the state attorney general office’s criminal bureau, called the move to free Nembhard “an inappropriate use of public funds.” He said prosecutors frequently work with cooperating witnesses while they are still in custody, holding out the prospect of a reduced sentence after they cooperate. But posting bail for the likes of Nembhard is over the top, he said.
“You might need to use someone nefarious in a murder case because you don’t have witnesses who are fine, upstanding citizens,” Cassidy said. “But bailing out someone who was caught with 30 bags of heroin, I would say that’s highly unusual and a cause for real concern.”
No wonder the Drug War is being lost.
Lewis A. Armistead Jr., a former Plymouth prosecutor who was briefly in charge of the Hess station case, said he resisted efforts to do favors for Nembhard and complained directly to Middleton about posting Nembhard’s bail.
“I nearly fell off my chair because at that point, I had been a prosecutor for probably 20 years and I’d never heard anything like that,” he said.
Nembhard quickly became a headache for Cruz’s office when he resumed his career as an armed drug dealer while still working as a government witness, records show.
See: FBI Thinks Frame-Ups Are Funny
You laughing, reader?
In February 2011, three months after state troopers bailed Nembhard out, police caught him selling crack cocaine. And when they searched his home they found an unlicensed handgun. By the time Nembhard testified about the Hess shooting before a grand jury in February 2012, he was behind bars facing federal charges and up to 15 years in prison.
Finally got 'em!
Further undermining Nembhard’s credibility as a witness was the fact that his bail being paid by the DA’s office was not reported to the grand jury or, as court rules require, to the defense, according to the defense attorney in the case, Michael A. Bergeron.
Oh, they BROKE THE LAW bring the CASE, huh?
Grand jury transcripts in the Hess shooting show that when Cruz’s investigator, Trooper Brian M. Galvin, was asked directly whether Nembhard had received “promises, rewards, or inducements” in exchange for his testimony, he said nothing about the bail money.
A more notorious Hess.
But in October 2012, O’Sullivan became concerned about the lack of disclosure. She privately told Bergeron, the lawyer for defendant Brian Price, who had been indicted on firearms charges, that Cruz’s office had paid Nembhard’s bail two years earlier.
Bergeron complained to the judge in the case. Two days later, Cruz dropped all charges.
The six-year-old murder of Antonio Centeio remains unsolved. But Cruz said his office did nothing wrong in its dealings with Nembhard, insisting his office dropped the case against Price because another witness had lied.
Oh, they lied! They lied!
“We believed and we still believe that it was ethically appropriate to make the bail arrangements,” Cruz said in his statement, noting that a judge later cleared both Galvin and the lead prosecutor of withholding information about the bail payment, accepting their assertion that any failure to disclose information was inadvertent. Cruz also said that Nembhard subsequently helped the office obtain three murder convictions.
These people are beyond redemption and hope.
However, Bergeron is not persuaded that he and his client were properly informed about the bail arrangement.
“Were it not for O’Sullivan having the courage of her convictions I would never have found out,” Bergeron said.
Former Plymouth prosecutors and defense attorneys say Cruz has exercised poor judgment in several additional instances where he cut deals with criminals to help solve murder cases, inadvertently clearing the way for more violent crime.
Cruz was especially generous with cooperating witness Olivio Leverone, agreeing in 2010 to drop illegal firearm charges in exchange for Leverone’s help in several unsolved homicides, according to the signed agreement between Leverone and Cruz’s office. The DA’s office also agreed to relocate Leverone to a new local apartment at a cost of $2,500 to taxpayers.
Is there really anything more to type?
Cruz said Leverone provided effective testimony, but just a year after the agreement to keep him out of prison, Leverone robbed a drug dealer, making off with approximately $225,000 in cash and several kilograms of cocaine, according to an affidavit by one of Cruz’s prosecutors.
The alleged theft triggered a feud that culminated in a New Year’s Eve 2011 shooting, after which Leverone was arrested for firing a gun.
Locked up and facing bail of $250,000, Leverone once again reached out to Cruz for help, in a handwritten letter.
“Hey Tim,” Leverone wrote in August 2012, “I know you need me to testify against several guys. Well I need you to, I want some help with my bail getting lower if not than I’m not testify.”
This time, Cruz did not come to the rescue. However, he still defends the use of Leverone as a witness, noting that he “provided important evidence on over a half-dozen violent felonies.”
Leverone is serving a three- to four-year prison sentence for assault with a dangerous weapon, and will serve additional time in a county jail for possession of an unlicensed firearm.
Persistent criminal behavior
A third cooperating witness, Linanel Brown-Madison, was indicted in the fatal shooting of Joshua LeClair during an attempted robbery on a residential street in Brockton in January 2013.
The Plymouth DA’s office worked with Brown-Madison for four years, starting in 2009, Cruz said, despite continuing bad behavior that included assaulting his girlfriend, impersonating a police officer, and having an unlicensed firearm in a motor vehicle — a charge that carries a mandatory prison term.
But they gotta get those guns away from YOU!
Brown-Madison provided grand jury testimony that helped prosecutors secure two indictments in a murder case, but the prosecutor who handled the case decided in August 2012 against using him as a witness during the trial. She was still able to obtain convictions.
“In my mind the witness had become a liability to my case because he was using his status as a cooperating witness as a license to commit crimes,” Tara Cappola told the Globe. Cappola left the office a year ago and is now in private practice.
Cruz, in his written comments to the Globe, said his office punished Brown-Madison appropriately when he broke the law, doing nothing to help him get out of jail after he was arrested on the unlicensed firearm charge. Brown-Madison remained in jail for 144 days until his girlfriend was able to post bail.
As if we are listening anymore. Scum!!!
He acknowledged, however, that his office agreed to reduce the firearms charge to one that did not carry a mandatory prison term so that Brown-Madison could be sentenced to probation and “continue to work on investigations with law enforcement.”
Brown-Madison has pleaded not guilty to murder and attempted robbery charges in the LeClair slaying.
Fallout from reluctant witness
Cruz’s problems with a fourth cooperating witness, Nilton Darosa, began with Darosa not wanting to cooperate on a murder case at all. He agreed to testify only under threat of deportation, according to the transcript of a 2010 jailhouse interview. And Cruz had to relocate his new witness out of state for his safety, at public expense.
Yeah, recent statistics and crime numbers have shown 75% of the drug crimes are committed by illegals. Comes with being a sanctuary city and state. Yay!
Darosa did testify against two accused murderers — a cousin, Joao Fernandes, and his alleged accomplice — in separate trials last winter.
But people who were there say his testimony against his cousin was lackluster, leading to a hung jury on the charge that Fernandes killed Manuel Rodrigues, who was gunned down after he testified before a grand jury about another murder.
“Nilton was a terrible witness,” said defense attorney Daniel S. Solomon. “He said different things at different times. And he kept adding to or taking away from his testimony.”
I wouldn't believe them. In fact, I never believe prosecution witnesses anymore. That's just the way it is in 21st-century AmeriKa.
Darosa then tried to back out of further testimony against the alleged accomplice, threatening to kill a prosecutor and two others if they tried to make him return to Massachusetts.
Eventually, Darosa relented, but his testimony was even less convincing, according to defense attorney Rosemary C. Scapicchio, and resulted in yet another hung jury.
From there, his relationship with prosecutors deteriorated quickly.
He didn't realize they were using him and would cut him loose in an instant?
After Darosa’s disappointing testimony, Cruz’s office asked Brockton police to investigate him and he was charged with carrying an unlicensed firearm.
That seems wrong somehow.
At his arraignment, Darosa became extremely agitated and said he would no longer testify, undermining the murder cases against Fernandes and his alleged accomplice.
Prosecutors have dropped plans to retry both defendants, and the Rodrigues murder remains unsolved.
“If you solve cases with bad witnesses, you end up with acquittals and hung juries at the other end of the pipeline,” said Daniel J. Hourihan, a former Plymouth prosecutor now working in Bristol County.
Business as usual
Today, Cruz is managing his office as if nothing were amiss, despite the judicial admonitions, the public criticism from his former prosecutors, and the loss of Middleton, his longtime right-hand man, who abruptly resigned this spring after 23 years with the Plymouth district attorney’s office.
It's called a STATE of DENIAL and DELUSION, or it is the HUBRIS of POWER and OFFICE!
Middleton said he was resigning to enter private practice, but he stepped down amid criticism of his decision to use the racially charged e-mails linked to former colleague O’Sullivan in an attempt to discredit her testimony in one of the Rodrigues murder cases. Some, including the defense attorney in the case, said the e-mails raised questions about whether some of Cruz’s prosecutors are racially biased.
No, that's okay in a government that serves supremacist Jews more than anyone (as their pre$$ waves the Confederate flag in your face!!)
“It’s not a matter of who wrote what to whom,” said Scapicchio, the defense attorney in the case. “The issue is: Is there a problem in the Plymouth County DA’s office that needs to be investigated?”
Cruz has denied any bias in his office, but has called in an outside consultant to review the issue.
“I remain committed to ensuring that all people involved in court cases . . . be treated fairly and equally, regardless of race,” Cruz said this year.
Meanwhile, pretrial testimony is going forward in the lawsuit filed by former Plymouth prosecutor Bradley, who accused Cruz of wrongly firing him.
Robert W. Harnais, president-elect of the Massachusetts Bar Association, said the multiple controversies in Cruz’s office are echoing through the legal community.
“The office seems to have a win-at-all costs, ends-justify-the-means attitude, and it just doesn’t work,” said Harnais.
“This isn’t about winning, it’s about justice.”
Where do they find these naive fools?
Well, now you understand why there is a gang problem in Brockton, 'eh?
And as if Cruz didn't have enough problems:
"Brockton man fatally shot after allegedly pointing BB gun at police" by Peter Schworm Globe Staff July 02, 2015
BROCKTON — Douglas Buckley had been drinking, and was threatening to burn down his home, his family told police. He was suicidal, his family said, and needed help.
Desperate, his wife went to the police station about 12:30 a.m. Thursday, hoping they could intervene and take him to the hospital. She said she told police he would probably not go quietly, but that he did not have any weapons, only some BB guns.
“I thought I was doing the right thing,” Barbara Buckley recalled Thursday from her Thayer Street home.
When two officers arrived on the quiet side street a short time later, they saw Buckley, 45, outside the home carrying what appeared to be a rifle while listening to the police scanner.
Buckley dropped the rifle and pulled out a handgun from his back and pointed it at the officers, who both fired, according to a statement from Plymouth District Attorney Timothy Cruz, whose office is investigating the shooting. Buckley was shot in the right lower abdomen, and later died.
Both the rifle and the handgun that Buckley allegedly pointed at police were BB guns that “closely resemble authentic guns,” Cruz’s office said.
The debate comes a little late for Buckley.
But Barbara Buckley said her husband posed no threat, and said police badly mishandled the situation.
Just a bump in the road, I'm sure.
“I repeatedly told them there were no weapons in the house,” she said. “The next thing I hear is ‘Drop it! Drop it!’ Then four pops. Four gunshots.”
Cruz’s office declined to say whether Buckley’s family had told them there were no weapons in the house, but noted that Buckley’s wife had called on her cellphone and told them he “had been drinking and made other threats” and that there were other people in the home.
Brockton police referred questions to prosecutors. The mayor’s office could not be reached for comment.
The shooting was believed to be the seventh police-involved fatal shooting this year in Massachusetts.
And they are supposed to be the model for the rest of the country, or so the Globe has told me!
Last month, an FBI agent and Boston police officer shot Usaamah Rahim, 26, in Roslindale after Rahim allegedly threatened the officers with a military knife. Rahim had been the target of an antiterrorism task force investigation.
I haven't posted a word about that.
On June 19, a Somerville man was shot and killed by a State Police trooper near Boston University after he allegedly refused to drop a knife and made threatening gestures, police said.
He deserved it.
In Brockton, Barbara Buckley said she explicitly told police about the BB guns, assuring them they were broken and not loaded.
I, of course, believe her over authority.
Buckley’s sister, Tara Fitzgerald, said police shot Buckley just moments after arriving at the house, and that he was climbing over a fence into the frontyard when they fired.
“How was he pointing a gun while climbing?” she asked. “I think they were very excessive and should be held accountable.’’
They were and won't be, but....
On Thursday, the fence lay in pieces on the grass, and bullet holes could be seen on the side of the house.
Fitzgerald said Buckley had personal troubles but was a good man who was deeply devoted to his wife and four children.
“He was a family man,” she said. “A good husband and father. He didn’t deserve this.”
No, he didn't.
Barbara Buckley said they had been married for 20 years. He grew up in Brockton, and worked as a sheet metal mechanic, she said.
Buckley was taken to Signature Health Care Brockton Hospital, where he was pronounced dead shortly after 2 a.m., authorities said.
After the shooting, Barbara Buckley’s 22-year-old son, Jesse Fernandes, was involved in an altercation with police, and was charged with assault and disorderly conduct.
They killed his father.
Prosecutors said he assaulted an officer when he returned home from the hospital. Family members said police punched him in the face, breaking his cheekbone and jaw.
One neighbor said Fernandes was furious about Buckley’s shooting and was hoping to find the police officer who was responsible.
He pleaded not guilty at his arraignment and was released.
Kevin Brown, a neighbor, placed flowers on the Buckley’s lawn as a memorial. He didn’t know the circumstances, but thought police could have found a way to subdue him without taking his life.
“I think they should have shot him in the leg to bring him down,” he said. “It’s just a sad day.”
Why would they want to do that? That would cost the authorities money and their would still be a useless eater to feed.
Cops reacted like that because BBs can kill (never mind that the guns were broken):
Teen shot, wounded inside Billerica home
Billerica teen dies from June pellet-gun shooting
"Pa. man shoots boy with BB gun, police say" Associated Press May 26, 2015
MCKEESPORT, Pa. — A Pennsylvania man shot an 11-year-old boy in the chest with a BB gun on a playground because he said the boy had previously shot his own young son with the same kind of weapon, authorities said Monday.
Albert Clark, 31, of McKeesport, approached the boy Sunday outside the former George Washington Elementary School and fired twice, police said. The boy fell to the ground, saying he couldn’t breathe and was later hospitalized in critical condition, police said.
Clark told investigators he then gave the weapon to a child who ‘‘was walking up the street,’’ according to a criminal complaint.
‘‘Clark stated that he was upset that the victim had shot his 5-year-old son with a [BB] gun in the buttocks the day before and that he had shot at his son again’’ on Sunday, investigators allege in the complaint.
Investigators searched Clark’s home and took 5,000 BB rounds. He faces charges including aggravated assault, reckless endangerment and evidence tampering, and was held in the county jail on $250,000 bail pending a June 1 preliminary hearing.
Maybe the cops should have BB guns instead. Sure would prevent something like this:
"State AG takes over probe into Brockton police shooting" by Jack Newsham Globe Correspondent July 07, 2015
Attorney General Maura Healey’s office is stepping in to investigate a lethal police shooting because of close relationships between members of the Plymouth district attorney’s office and Brockton police.
Douglas Buckley had been drinking and was suicidal when he was fatally shot by Brockton police early Thursday morning, family members said.
See? Just assisting and serving a citizen.
Plymouth District Attorney Timothy Cruz asked Healey’s office to take over the investigation because Cruz and others in his office know the officers involved, according to a joint statement by the authorities.
He's such an above-board kind of guy!
In early statements following the shooting, Cruz’s office said Buckley, 45, was carrying what appeared to be a rifle outside his home when police officers arrived around 12:30 a.m. Thursday.
After Buckley pulled a handgun from his back and pointed it at officers, they shot him in the abdomen. He was pronounced dead at Signature Health Care Brockton Hospital.
Police later discovered that the weapons were BB guns.
The witness who called it in says she told 911 all that.
Of course, the Globe would never distort anything.
“The Attorney General’s Office will investigate these incidents involving three Brockton police officers thoroughly, independently, and transparently,” said Emalie Gainey, a spokeswoman for Healey’s office.
Barbara Buckley, the wife of the victim, walked into the police department to report that her husband had threatened to burn down the house, but she said she told police there were no weapons in the house.
I thought it was a telephone call. That means cops are covering it up, and Globe is helping them.
The case is the first time Healey has investigated a police shooting since she took office in January, according to Gainey. The attorney general’s office is also investigating an alleged racially motivated beating by Worcester police officer Michael Motyka Dec. 1 in a cell at police headquarters.
See: Alleged Worcester beating latest in a pattern
Anyone remember Ken Howe?
The attorney general’s office will also be investigating assault charges filed against Jesse Fernandes, Buckley’s 22-year-old son, who was accused of assaulting officers after returning from the hospital. Family members and a neighbor said Fernandes was punched in the face while trying to find the officer who killed his father.
I'm acquitting the boy.
As if things weren't bad enough for poor Cruz, now the FBI is getting involved.
"Authorities say one man was killed and two others injured in an early morning shooting and stabbing in Brockton. The Enterprise of Brockton reported that police were searching Sunday near a large multifamily home on Green Street where witnesses said there was a fight at a party that moved outside. Plymouth District Attorney Timothy Cruz said police were called to the building for shots fired around 4:30 a.m. He said police found one of the wounded men, and witnesses said two others had been taken to a hospital in private cars. Cruz said the man who died was shot in the chest. He said another man who was stabbed and a third man who was shot in the leg had surgery for their injuries, which are not considered life-threatening. The victims’ names were not released."
UPDATE: Brockton woman, 89, hogtied during home invasion
You know how and why that is possible.